A beer dinner that could have been great!

Well we are fans of the guys at Sardine so when the chance to attend their first beer harvest dinner was presented we jumped at the chance. We love to sit at the bar and have dinner often because the gang at the bar deliver some of the best service in Madison. When Nate suggested that we sign up for what was going to be an evening of great Belgian Beer and hearty fare we thought what a great way to spend a Monday evening.

So we rolled in on Monday October 27th to enjoy some hors d'oeuvre and ale, sadly the snacks were some cheese and crackers not very exciting for a bar area full of folks really quaffing the brew. So we chalked it up to just a small miss. They promptly seated everyone at 7:15 to serve a family style meal. We sat with a lovely couple who enjoyed dining and travel and seemed quite pleased with the evenings fare. We started out with a bang - some wonderful roasted mussels on the half shell with a herb crumb mixture with butter - quite tasty with a hint of tarragon that paired the dish well with the Leffe Blonde. The beer was a Belgian ale with just a hint of anise on the finish this was a great pairing with the mussels. The other first course was a salad of frisee with shaved fennel, apple, blue cheese and walnuts lightly dressed - it was light, crispy and tart which also went nicely with the Leffe Blonde. It was at this point in the meal that we had expected either John or Phillip to greet the crowd and share their insights for the evening meal, however they remained in the kitchen. It was a huge miss that no one discussed the beer or the food as we have experienced at wine dinners around town.

Instead the next two beers were served in preparation for the entree courses being served, these were the Spaten Oktoberfest and the Kasteel Brune. Both heavier beers designed to go with the braised chicken, roasted fall vegetables, and a platter of various sausages. The food was ok - tepid - the sausage platter with fresh sauerkraut was just that - not interesting again no really explanation or guidance from our hosts. The beers were great with these items so a lot of thought was put into the pairing but no one shared the thinking or insights - a huge miss for a number of foodies in attendance. The Spaten had nice caramel notes with a light hoppy finish - pleasing to drink, the Kasteel Brune was rich, dark and coffee, like it held up to the boldness of the roasted squash and brussel sprouts with out over powering their flavors. All in all the second course was disappointing on many levels. So we hoped that the dessert course would pull the evening out of the sub par experience but it failed to do so.

What arrived for dessert was an apple strudel that was ok but tended to have a gummy crust and it did not pair well with the Floris Framboise. Which was a light and bubbly lambic with a lovely raspberry nose it would have been better with something chocolate that would have provided a contrast to the beer. Ok now is someone going to come out and talk to the crowd, maybe say a few words and thank everyone (all very regular guests) for coming tonight. Nope the next thing that shows up is the check. So we cash out say goodbye to the couple we sat with and the gang behind the bar. What we hoped to be a stellar evening turns our to be a B- at best.

Part of what makes Sardine and Marigold Kitchen special is the hospitality and the people who have passion to serve. We go to Sardine as I said for the excellent service at the bar from Gabe, Nate and Bobbi it is too bad that hospitality was lacking on what could have been a great evening. I think maybe John and Phillip should attend a wine dinner at Harvest to see how gracious Tammi and her team execute what is a lovely evening of food, wine and knowledge with their guests. We will give the gang at Sardine another try on a paired dinner - we hope this first outing provided some good feedback for the team and will help them raise the bar. We know that a number of folks dinning at the harvest dinner were interested in more than just chowing down, they came thirsty for knowledge with a willingness to learn and grow.